Friend or Foe?: Navigating Body Image and Social Media Influence
Faculty Sponsor(s)
Tanya L Tompkins and Kiki A Fornero
Subject Area
Psychology
Description
Social media use is pervasive and represents a double-edged sword, offering potentially destructive and constructive experiences for its users. As part of a larger mixed-method study focused on individuals impacted by feminine appearance standards, this qualitative descriptive study investigates the impact of social media and body image among eight participants (ages 19-30, gender and ethnically diverse). Each participant responded to questions about the evolution of positive and negative body image and the impact of social media content, including body positivity, throughout their lives. Participants were also asked to view and respond to four ideal or non-ideal Instagram images with reinforcing and challenging comments. Thematic analysis of interviews revealed key themes including: 1) strong influence of social media on appearance, fashion, consumerism and productivity; 2) cognitive dissonance in negotiating body positivity, acceptance and neutrality; 3) body image disturbance, objectification and internalized appearance norms; 4) negative impact of body commentary, both in-person and online; 5) push/pull relationship with social media engagement. Participants’ perspectives highlight the need for change in online spaces by fostering authenticity and empowering users to assert agency over their digital experiences. Key areas for improvement include comment moderation, social media literacy, and the promotion of diverse and inclusive content.
Recommended Citation
Dewey, Samantha F.; Fender, Emily D.; Wright, Maya A.; Gerges, Rana T.; Fornero, Kiki A.; Tompkins, Tanya L.; and Porter, Rosemary L., "Friend or Foe?: Navigating Body Image and Social Media Influence" (2025). Linfield University Student Symposium: A Celebration of Scholarship and Creative Achievement. Event. Submission 17.
https://digitalcommons.linfield.edu/symposium/2025/all/17
Friend or Foe?: Navigating Body Image and Social Media Influence
Social media use is pervasive and represents a double-edged sword, offering potentially destructive and constructive experiences for its users. As part of a larger mixed-method study focused on individuals impacted by feminine appearance standards, this qualitative descriptive study investigates the impact of social media and body image among eight participants (ages 19-30, gender and ethnically diverse). Each participant responded to questions about the evolution of positive and negative body image and the impact of social media content, including body positivity, throughout their lives. Participants were also asked to view and respond to four ideal or non-ideal Instagram images with reinforcing and challenging comments. Thematic analysis of interviews revealed key themes including: 1) strong influence of social media on appearance, fashion, consumerism and productivity; 2) cognitive dissonance in negotiating body positivity, acceptance and neutrality; 3) body image disturbance, objectification and internalized appearance norms; 4) negative impact of body commentary, both in-person and online; 5) push/pull relationship with social media engagement. Participants’ perspectives highlight the need for change in online spaces by fostering authenticity and empowering users to assert agency over their digital experiences. Key areas for improvement include comment moderation, social media literacy, and the promotion of diverse and inclusive content.
